Home | Business News | Browse by Publication | N | Notes

Symphonic Aspirations: German Music and Politics, 1900-1945.

Article Excerpt
Symphonic Aspirations: German Music and Politics, 1900-1945. By Karen Painter. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007. [vi, 354 p. ISBN-13: 9780674026612. $49.95.] Index, bibliographical references.

The title of Karen Painter's most recent book can be read to imply a lot of things, but few readers would be likely to divine from it the book's stared purpose: namely, "to recover the listening, habits and aesthetic values these writers [music critics] as-pired to instill in the public, along with the political and cultural values they passionately believed were at stake and at risk" (p. 2). The "symphonic" in the title alludes to Painter's intention to study critical reactions in the German cultural sphere to the German symphonic tradition. None of this is strictly maintained for long. Soon one reads that "[a]s a study of the symphony"--not the reception history of the symphony--"in Austria and Germany in the twentieth century, this book goes against the grain" (p. 4), and in fact, her book does on occasion shift perspective from that of the critic to that of the composer. This is to some degree unavoidable and even necessary, as symphonies continued to be written throughout the time period in question, and a composer's words about his music are just as much a part of its reception history as anyone else's. In order to explain the decline in symphonic production in that time and place, some consideration of the composer's perspective is certainly in order.

Much more troubling are Painter's notions, sometimes stated outright and sometimes implied, concerning the nature of the symphony and the limits of the German symphonic tradition. To some degree this can be attributed to her frequently and astonishingly clumsy prose, which throughout the book serves, however unintentionally, to either obscure the dubiousness or compromise the validity of an assertion. In three successive sentences, the symphony progresses from inanimate locus ("an open arena to be invested with meaning") to animate victim ("prey to the broadest cultural and political claims") to human agent ("the symphony promised a transcendence of its own sonority," p. 4). There are contexts in which any one of these metaphors can be useful, but in a work on critical reception and listening habits, the latter two serve only to obfuscate. One sees this with regard to specific works as well as with the genre as a whole. Taking a cue from its earliest critics and, to be fair, from the composer himself, Painter describes the last movement of Mahler's Seventh Symphony as "a rejoicing finale" (p. 1) and "effervescent" (p. 25), and refers to the "strict form" of its "jubilation" (p. 105). She mentions Adorno's characterization of the movement ("a poor yea-sayer," p.1) only to dismiss it without comment; she takes Julius Korngold's initial praise of its " 'ecstatic...

View this article FREE - Now for a Limited Time, try Goliath Business News
Free for 3 Days!